A tiny dot beside Halyn Roth’s name helped decide who would be the next mayor of Spring Lake Park, Minnesota. The ballot had a much more distinct mark beside the name of incumbent Mayor Robert Nelson, and election workers initially determined the voter intended to vote for him. Roth challenged that call. When the city’s canvassing board ruled that neither candidate would receive the vote, Roth won the election by a single vote.
Spring Lake Park voters had given the two men exactly 1,401 votes apiece in the initial count on November 3rd. Minnesota law calls for a drawing to settle a tied city election, so on November 9th, city officials put the candidates’ names in a bag. Council Member Barbara Goodboe-Bisschoff drew Nelson’s name, giving the longtime mayor another term unless a recount changed the result.
Roth had come to the drawing prepared for that possibility. After Nelson’s name came out of the bag, Roth handed City Administrator Daniel Buchholtz a completed request for a recount. Election workers would examine the ballots by hand at the Anoka County Courthouse on November 17th. If the candidates finished even again, the city would honor the original drawing and Nelson would keep his seat.
Roth accepted how the city had conducted the drawing, telling FOX 9 in its coverage that evening, “It was fair as far as it could be. Can’t imagine any other way we could have done it.” Nelson himself had reservations about choosing a mayor that way. “This seems like it’s something from the 1800s, and now we’re in 2026,” he told CBS Minnesota.
During the recount, both men asked election workers to take a closer look at several ballots. Buchholtz told MPR News that a voter might cross out one oval and fill in another, leaving a machine unable to count a choice that a person inspecting the ballot could recognize. After several hours, the candidates agreed with the counters on every ballot they had questioned except the one with marks beside both men’s names.
That ballot went to the City Council, whose members sit as the municipal canvassing board. Buchholtz recommended counting the vote for Nelson. Council Member Ken Wendling said he and two colleagues examined both sides of the ballot to see how the voter had marked other races. In their judgment, the pen mark in Nelson’s oval was less distinct than the marks the same voter had made for candidates elsewhere on the ballot.
See FOX 9’s coverage of the drawing that initially gave Nelson the mayor’s seat here:
"*" indicates required fields
Wendling and two other members voted to sustain Roth’s challenge. Nelson abstained, and Goodboe-Bisschoff, the council member who’d drawn his name eight days earlier, cast the lone vote to count the ballot for him. Roth told CBS Minnesota that recount adjustments had already put him ahead 1,403 votes to 1,402 before the board ruled on the disputed ballot. With that vote excluded from the mayoral tally, the city certified Roth as mayor-elect.
Nelson has seven days from the board’s decision to contest the result in Anoka County District Court. A judge who determines the disputed vote should count for Nelson could restore the tie that the mayor won in the drawing. Roth said he was preparing to take office and acknowledged Nelson’s right to bring a challenge. Wendling told MPR News that as Nelson walked out of the council chambers, the mayor said, “See you in court.”
Featured image credit: screengrab from the embedded video.