Close Menu
The American Tribune.com
    Telegram Facebook
    The American Tribune.com
    • Home
    • Political Commentary
    • Business and Economy Commentary
    • Entertainment Commentary
    • Sports Commentary
    • General Commentary
    The American Tribune.com
    General Commentary

    Police Seize Ballots in Razor-Thin Election Race after Data Shows More Votes than Voters

    By Russell WallaceNovember 20, 2026
    Facebook Twitter Email

    Indiana ordered ballots impounded in a state Senate race in which Republican Senator Chris Garten led Democrat Nick Marshall by 297 votes in the election-night returns. Four precincts had recorded 28 more ballots than voter check-ins. Garten filed the recount request that prompted the order. By the following day, Clark County Democrats had filed a challenge of their own.

    The four precincts shared a polling place at Jeffersonville High School in southern Indiana. On Election Day, an electronic poll book used to check in voters malfunctioned, and a paper ballot jammed in a scanner at about 11 a.m. Election officials replaced the top section of the machine and transferred the data stick while representatives of both parties watched. The paper ballots remained in the bottom section.

    Garten, a Republican from Charlestown, was seeking a third term representing District 45, which takes in all of Clark County and part of neighboring Floyd County. His lead over Marshall amounted to about two-thirds of a percentage point across the district. The immediate question for lawmakers was whether Garten could take his oath when the Senate convened to choose its next leader.

    The Clark County Election Board met on November 10th to consider a physical count of the ballots from the high school. Its members disagreed over whether they had the authority to open the ballot containers. The two Republicans voted against proceeding after concluding that officials had adequately investigated the precinct returns, as The Indiana Citizen reported. Democrats questioned whether a printed tally time-stamped 11:08 a.m. included ballots cast that morning. In a November 11th statement, state Democratic Chair Karen Tallian and 9th District Chair Adam Dickey said, “There may be several hours of votes that were not counted.”

    The dispute reached the courts on the eve of the Senate’s Organization Day. Scott County Circuit Court Judge Jason Mount, hearing the Clark County case, temporarily barred Garten from taking his seat, prompting the senator to seek emergency relief from the Indiana Supreme Court. On Tuesday, November 17th, the justices lifted the part of the order that kept him from taking office. Garten took the oath that afternoon, and his colleagues elected him president pro tempore, the chamber’s top leadership post, as the Indiana Capital Chronicle reported.

    On the Senate floor, with Republican colleagues standing behind him, Garten announced that he would ask for a recount himself. His petition specified the four Jeffersonville precincts whose voters had shared the malfunctioning equipment. “I want the process to be transparent, the results to be verified and the will of the voters to be respected,” Garten said in remarks reported by WDRB+WAVE.

    Watch the video here:

    "*" indicates required fields

    This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
    GOP should investigate Nancy Pelosi*
    This poll subscribes you to our premium network of content. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Acting on Garten’s petition, the Indiana Recount Commission directed county election officials to work with the Indiana State Police and the State Board of Accounts to secure the election materials. According to the Election Issues Monitor’s account of the order, it covered the ballots, the voting equipment and the electronic poll books used to record who appeared at the polls. It also covered tally sheets and absentee voting records, including applications and envelopes.

    On Wednesday, November 18th, Clark County Democratic Chair Miguel Hampton filed the party’s petition for a recount and an election contest, as FOX59 reported. Hampton asked the commission to combine the two petitions and count ballots by hand in all 86 precincts, which would extend the review into Floyd County. Citing equipment problems at multiple polling places, Hampton also asked the commission to order a special election for the Senate seat if its findings warrant one, according to the Indiana Capital Chronicle’s account of the filing.

    Featured image credit: screengrab from the embedded video

    Special For American Tribune


    Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube Telegram
    • About
    • Contributors
    • Curation Policy
    • Affiliate Disclosure
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service
    Copyright 2022 The American Tribune

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.