The Justice Department has issued more than 200 subpoenas to investigate how a retired Alaska teacher with the same name as Republican Senator Dan Sullivan wound up running against him. Federal investigators are examining allegations that Democratic operatives went looking for a second Dan Sullivan who could draw votes away from the incumbent. Democrat Mary Peltola won the Senate seat, and the criminal investigation has continued beyond Election Day.
Alaskans who went to the polls on November 3rd found four names on the Senate ballot. Dan S. Sullivan was the Republican senator seeking reelection. Daniel J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from the southeastern Alaska town of Petersburg, appeared on the ballot without a party designation. The other two candidates were Peltola, who had previously represented Alaska in the U.S. House, and Gerald L. Heikes, a Republican.
The two Sullivans had already been the subject of a fight in state court before voters made their choices. Alaska election officials initially moved to take the Petersburg candidate off the primary ballot over concerns that voters looking for the senator might mistakenly select his namesake. The retired teacher denied wrongdoing, and the Alaska Supreme Court ruled that he could stay in the race. His campaign raised $35,556.
Two sources confirmed the subpoena count to Fox News Digital, which reported the figure on November 18th. A law enforcement source told the outlet that investigators were pursuing multiple targets across state lines. Among those who received a criminal target letter was Marc Elias, the Democratic attorney whose firm represents Peltola’s campaign. The letter identified Elias as a target of the investigation. It carried no criminal charge.
The allegations reached beyond Alaska to the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and centered on a candidate recruitment effort described as the “ballot composition project.” Peltola’s campaign and the committee denied wrongdoing. President Donald Trump called on Peltola to leave the race and addressed the search for a candidate during an Election Day appearance on “Fox & Friends.” Trump said, “But you had the Democrat Party look all over Alaska for somebody named Sullivan.”
When the race was called on November 17th, two weeks after Election Day, Peltola had 144,302 votes to the senator’s 131,844. Heikes received 6,105 votes, putting him third, and the second Sullivan finished fourth with 4,760. Peltola’s lead over the incumbent was 12,458 votes, more than the combined total for the two candidates who finished behind him.
See the October 30th Fox News report on the subpoenas here.
"*" indicates required fields
The Justice Department had also gone to federal court in October to seek a delay in certifying the Senate results if confusion over the names could have changed the outcome. In that civil case, the department wanted time to examine whether voters who marked the retired teacher’s name had meant to vote for the senator. A federal judge dismissed the case, finding that the department had failed to show how a court order could remedy the harm it alleged. The department appealed that ruling to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
On November 19th, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward told the appeals court that the government’s civil case was moot, Reuters reported. By then, the ballots had been counted together, and election officials could no longer match a ballot marked for Daniel J. Sullivan to the voter who cast it. In the department’s filing, Woodward asked the appeals court to vacate the lower court’s ruling and send the case back for dismissal.
Featured image credit: screengrab from the embedded video.