A Christmas video that Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins sent to roughly 100,000 employees is now at the center of a federal court order restricting how she can discuss religion in department-wide emails. U.S. District Judge Trina L. Thompson issued the preliminary injunction on November 19th, a week before Thanksgiving. The Biden appointee took particular issue with Rollins speaking of Jesus as “our Savior” in a message sent to every employee’s work inbox.
The National Federation of Federal Employees and six Agriculture Department workers sued Rollins and the department in May. The six work in different parts of the agency, and none belongs to the union, which represents more than 19,000 USDA employees. At an October 27th hearing in San Francisco, Thompson heard the workers’ request for an order limiting the secretary’s messages and the Trump administration’s request to dismiss the case.
Rollins had been writing to employees on federal holidays since her first year in office. She closed her July 4th, 2025, email by asking God to protect the United States. The day before Thanksgiving, she wrote about the gratitude to God that brought two peoples together in 1621. For Christmas, she recorded a video and sent it to the department on December 23rd under the subject line “Merry Christmas from Secretary Rollins.”
In their complaint, the employees quoted Rollins describing the birth of Christ as the source of the generosity Americans show at Christmas. She spoke of Jesus coming to “free us from our sins and open the door to eternal life.” On Easter Sunday, April 5th, Rollins sent another message, this time with an illustration of the stone rolled away from Christ’s tomb. Beneath it, she addressed the staff as “Team USDA” and called the Resurrection “the foundation of our faith.”
The employees explained why they opened holiday messages from the secretary. USDA leadership had used those emails to announce administrative leave, and other communications from the same office had addressed relocations, shutdown preparations and changes to the agency. One employee, Lanette Dietrich, said she was told she could not be removed from the distribution list. In her order, Thompson pointed out that everyone on the list ultimately reported to the official who sent the messages.
Thompson acknowledged that Rollins had neither singled out employees who disagreed with her nor suggested that anyone’s job depended on a response. The judge focused on the passage of the Easter email in which Rollins compared employees to the disciples who encountered Jesus after the Resurrection. Thompson also cited a public statement from Rollins about speaking openly of her faith while serving as secretary. As Rollins put it, “I’ll never stop talking about Jesus.”
Watch Rollins at USDA’s December 2025 Christmas tree lighting here:
"*" indicates required fields
To set the terms of the injunction, Thompson turned to workplace guidance the department had issued under Rollins. It allows the secretary to talk with interested colleagues about her beliefs, explain what her faith means to her and invite coworkers to religious services. It also directs her to stop when a colleague asks her to and bars her from using her authority to pressure subordinates about religion.
The department prevailed on a separate part of the suit. Thompson dismissed the employees’ claims under the Administrative Procedure Act because the holiday emails neither established a rule nor decided an agency matter. The First Amendment claim will proceed. The Associated Press reported that a USDA spokesperson said the department was considering an appeal and called the ruling “a completely unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary.”
Featured image credit: screengrab from the embedded video.