Senator John Cornyn’s (R-TX) voice carried all the way to the press gallery Tuesday as he confronted fellow Texas Republican Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) over one of President Donald Trump’s judicial nominees. Cruz wanted T. Elliot Gaiser to get a hearing for a federal judgeship in Dallas. Cornyn refused to sign off. By Wednesday, the Senate Judiciary Committee was hearing from other Trump nominees, and Gaiser was off the hearing agenda.
The two senators were on the floor of a mostly empty Senate chamber on November 17th when the argument broke out. Trump had picked Gaiser, a Justice Department official and Ohio lawyer, for the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. For a district court nomination, the Judiciary Committee traditionally asks both senators from the state where the court vacancy exists to return a form.
That form is known on Capitol Hill as a blue slip. That custom gave Cornyn the power to stop Gaiser before his name ever came up for a vote. It also left Trump with little time to find another candidate for Dallas. Democrats are set to take control of the Senate on January 3rd. The incoming majority will then decide which of the president’s judicial picks get hearings.
“I don’t find you credible. I’m mad at you!” Cornyn told Cruz, according to The Washington Sun’s eyewitness account. Reporters heard Cornyn blame someone “for ending my career!” but couldn’t tell whether he meant Cruz or Trump. Cruz answered too quietly for them to hear. Cornyn’s reply carried just fine. “Oh, that’s bulls–t!” he said, waving Cruz off and walking toward the Democratic side of the chamber.
Cornyn had lost the Republican Senate primary to Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton after Trump endorsed the challenger. Cruz stayed neutral in the race, although Axiom Strategies, the firm associated with his political operation, worked for Paxton. Democrat James Talarico went on to defeat Paxton in the general election. When reporters asked Cruz afterward why Cornyn had been so angry with him, he answered, “You’d have to ask him.”
Cornyn was more willing to discuss his objections to Gaiser. He told Reuters that Gaiser lacked trial experience and that the White House had given the senators too little opportunity to examine his qualifications for a lifetime appointment. On Wednesday, Cornyn told The Associated Press that he intended to keep his blue slip. Cruz warned that blocking Gaiser would “effectively give the judicial seat to the Democrats, who will keep it vacant in perpetuity.”
Watch Cornyn introduce Trump’s other Texas district court nominee at Wednesday’s hearing:
"*" indicates required fields
Cornyn took a seat at the Judiciary Committee hearing that morning to introduce James Sullivan, Trump’s choice for the Western District of Texas. In his opening remarks, Cornyn described the bipartisan panel he and Cruz had used for years to evaluate candidates for the federal bench. Gaiser had never gone through that review. Sullivan had, and Cornyn told the committee the Texas Supreme Court justice earned high marks.
Cornyn drew on his own seven years on the Texas Supreme Court as he introduced Sullivan to his colleagues. He pointed to Sullivan’s earlier work as general counsel to Governor Greg Abbott and traced his Texas ties back to his days playing football at Westlake High School in Austin. Cornyn then addressed Sullivan directly. “Congratulations, James, on your nomination, and I look forward to supporting your confirmation here in the committee and on the Senate floor.”
Featured image credit: screengrab from the embedded video.