Fox News host Lawrence Jones and Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH) got into a heated conversation about whether Democrats have called for illegal immigrants to have access to healthcare. Shaheen denied that her party had made any such statements, but Jones had tape to support his side of the argument.
Shaheen joined Jones for a conversation on the network’s popular “Fox & Friends” program where the two discussed this particular issue during a government shutdown that was due in large part to Republicans and Democrats not being able to come to an agreement on subsidies for the Affordable Care Act (ACA) being extended and Medicaid cuts to be reversed.
At the time, in October 2025, Republicans, along with President Donald Trump, slammed Democrats with accusations that they were fighting for healthcare for illegal aliens. Shaheen said that those arguments were nothing more than a “red herring,” but Jones kept the receipts to verify his point.
“The illegal immigrant is just a red herring that’s designed to try and prevent people from talking about the real issue, which is how do we provide health insurance for people in this country,” Shaheen said, according to a report from Yahoo. “You know, I say a little detail, you say red herring, but the fact is, Senator, that it exists,” Jones replied.
“No, listen, I’m agreeing with you,” she went on to tell Jones. “You’re trying to make an issue where there isn’t one. We agree! Illegal immigrants should not be getting access to the Affordable Care Act marketplace.” Jones then said, “100%, senator, but what I’m saying is that members of your party are making this an issue.”
“Well, I can’t speak for members of my party, and I don’t think you’re right,” Shaheen fired back immediately, coming to the defense of her Democratic colleagues. The New Hampshire Democrat then tried to accuse Vice President JD Vance of making healthcare for illegal immigrants an issue.
Vance had appeared on the program the previous day, agreeing with many of the points President Trump made on the shutdown. He also made the case that he’s willing to negotiate on healthcare points, but only after a funding deal was put into place. “I think you are making it an issue,” Shaheen said to Jones.
"*" indicates required fields
“Vice President Vance is making it an issue, but I haven’t heard anybody in my party saying that illegal immigrants should get access to the health insurance market,” she continued. And that’s when Jones brought out the receipts and officially cooked Shaheen’s goose. “I’m so glad you said that,” he started.
“Actually, I have some tape of your Democratic party members saying this on the debate stage. So they’ve all said, and let’s play the clip,” Jones added. He then cut to a clip from a 2019 Democratic debate where every single individual on the stage raised their hand in support of healthcare plans that would include coverage for illegal aliens.
One of those individuals was none other than former President Joe Biden, the man whose policies led to the immigration crisis that conservatives say Trump has been trying to clean up for the last two years. Jones then hammered the point home by noting that most of the popular individuals in the party were on the stage.
“Senator, that’s literally every member of your party from moderate to more progressive that have said that in the past. I’ve seen them all on cable,” Jones said to the New Hampshire senator. Shaheen then clarified that she herself has never publicly supported that position and that her state does not provide illegal aliens with healthcare.
“I beg to disagree with you. I have not said that in the past. In New Hampshire, we do not provide health insurance for illegal immigrants. We have never done that, and you’re just wrong!” Shaheen concluded. “So the question right now is what are we going to do to ensure that we’re not kicking 24 million Americans, raising their premiums for health insurance, doubling those, and kicking 4 million Americans off of their health insurance.”
Featured Image: screenshot from embedded video