New Jersey’s largest teachers union is facing federal scrutiny over roughly $40 million spent promoting its former president’s unsuccessful bid for governor. Investigators are examining political spending connected to the New Jersey Education Association and Sean Spiller’s 2025 Democratic primary campaign. Several people associated with a super PAC supporting Spiller have reportedly received subpoenas.
Spiller sought the Democratic nomination while leading a union representing approximately 200,000 members. The spending operation involved Garden State Forward, a union-affiliated super PAC, and Working New Jersey, another super PAC run by former NJEA officials. Money passed through those organizations to finance advertising and other efforts promoting his candidacy.
The expensive campaign ended with Spiller finishing fifth in a six-candidate field, receiving 10.6% of the vote. Mikie Sherrill won the nomination and subsequently became governor. Spiller’s own campaign raised and spent comparatively little alongside the outside operation backing him.
The Daily Caller News Foundation reported that at least one subpoena came from the U.S. Attorney’s Office in New Jersey, citing Politico’s reporting. The specific suspected violations remained unclear, and the reporting described an investigation rather than criminal charges. The U.S. Attorney’s Office declined to comment.
Questions about teachers’ knowledge of the spending had surfaced during the campaign. In an April 15th, 2025, NJ Spotlight News interview, NJ Advance Media reporter Brent Johnson discussed reporting he conducted with colleague Riley Yates on the union’s financial support for Spiller. Johnson said several recently retired teachers contacted for their reporting had been unaware their dues were being used that way. Some teachers supported Spiller’s candidacy, while others objected to how their money was being spent.
Johnson also discussed Spiller’s failure to qualify for an upcoming debate because he had not qualified for state matching funds. The outside spending nevertheless gave him substantial advertising exposure through television, flyers and billboards. Asked about the source of that support, Johnson said, “Sean Spiller told me that yes union dues are going to this.” The interview occurred before the primary defeat and the subsequent reporting about federal subpoenas.
See NJ Spotlight News’s April 2025 interview about the campaign’s financing here:
"*" indicates required fields
The spending also prompted a separate civil lawsuit from teachers Marie Dupont and Ann Marie Pocklembo. Their September 30th, 2025, complaint accused NJEA and Spiller of breaching obligations to members, including promises concerning voluntary political contributions. Pocklembo said she had declined to authorize those contributions, while Dupont had stopped making them.
They alleged that regular membership dues nevertheless funded political organizations supporting Spiller, and sought damages and other relief. The complaint also alleged that Spiller held decision-making positions in both the union’s political operation and Protecting Our Democracy. It accused him of using those positions to advance his own campaign at members’ expense, in violation of duties to put their interests first.
The Fairness Center, which represents the teachers, said Pocklembo also alleged retaliation after questioning the spending on Facebook. According to the organization’s account, she said she was blocked from union pages and later instructed by union leaders to “be a team player.” Dupont resigned her membership in protest. “I never agreed to bankroll a politician,” Pocklembo said.
Featured image credit: screengrab from the embedded video.