Atlanta’s Democratic mayor lashed out at one of his own constituents, telling the voter to “shut up” after he pressed the mayor about transportation projects Atlanta residents were promised. The confrontation began beneath a lighthearted social media video before quickly turning into a public fight over City Hall’s handling of criticism. Constituent Jonathan Brimer accused Mayor Andre Dickens of failing to deliver pedestrian improvements and BeltLine rail. Dickens responded by demanding that Brimer respect the women featured in the video.
Dickens had posted footage of himself visiting the Nature Gurlz, a group of black women who began meeting for outdoor walks during the COVID-19 pandemic. “Nothing like seeing folks outside, enjoying each other and enjoying this city,” the mayor said in the post. Brimer used the comment section to raise concerns about Peachtree Street and Atlanta’s transportation network. His comment focused on projects that voters had agreed to help finance through additional sales taxes.
“Have some fun by restoring Peachtree St’s pedestrian-centric design in downtown and by delivering what we voted for with extra sales taxes for MARTA by getting Beltline rail done,” Brimer wrote. MARTA is the Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Authority, which operates bus and rail service throughout the Atlanta area. Brimer’s complaint focused on the city’s handling of those transportation plans.
The mayor fired back, “Shut up and respect our legacy black women residents that made this city that you get to enjoy freely. We on the southside today.” As Trending Politics News reported, the response quickly drew criticism from Brimer and several other Atlanta residents who considered the mayor’s behavior inappropriate.
“Wow a mayor telling a constituent to shut up for asking him to uphold voter mandates,” Brimer responded. “Stay classy, Andre.” He added that he lives on Atlanta’s south side and appreciates his neighbors, rejecting the implication that his transportation criticism showed any type of disrespect toward the women in the video Dickens had originally posted.
“What I don’t appreciate is your lack of leadership, lack of transparency, lack of responding to criticism publicly and your tendency to dismiss legitimate criticism instead of answering it,” Brimer continued. “Respect for Atlanta’s residents should include respecting constituents who challenge you. Telling one to ‘shut up’ is not leadership.” Brimer later shared a screenshot of the exchange and described the mayor’s response as “wildly inappropriate.”
Brimer told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution that he had not expected Dickens to respond at all. “The fact that it was aggressive by public servant standards added a little extra surprise, I suppose,” he said. Brimer said he had spoken with Dickens years earlier, while Dickens was serving on the Atlanta City Council, and had initially supported his campaign for mayor.
"*" indicates required fields
Other users criticized Dickens for attacking a resident who had simply raised a policy complaint. “The sharp response you offer doesn’t bode well,” one commenter wrote. Another told Dickens, “Listen to your residents. Invest in transit. Support Beltline rail. Very disappointed in you, Mayor.”
Brimer’s complaint concerned Atlanta’s BeltLine project, which is intended to connect more than 45 neighborhoods through a 22-mile loop of trails and transit. The massive redevelopment project is expected to cost approximately $4.8 billion and is scheduled for completion by 2030. Dickens also supports MARTA’s roughly five-mile Rapid A-Line connecting downtown Atlanta with the BeltLine’s Southside Trail, portions of which remain under construction.
Dickens won reelection outright on November 4, 2025, and is now serving his second consecutive four-year term as Atlanta’s mayor. City rules prevent a mayor who has served two consecutive terms from seeking a third consecutive term, meaning Dickens’ current tenure is scheduled to end in January 2030. As of August 20, Dickens had not publicly apologized for the remark, and his office declined to comment when asked whether he planned to do so.